Report a player - 880 and 889 - GTA RP

[BeercanButty]

Server: GTA RP
Your Character Name: James Fellow
Reported Players: 880 and 889
Date: May 25, 2025
Time: 01:30
What best describes this incident: (G2.12) Poor Quality Roleplay
Please (in detail) describe the incident: So again hustlers and Cutlass have been having a beef tonight we flew in to do some hot zone little did we know cutlass would be around we ended up having a little fight where a few of our members was grabbed with the remaining 4 of us we decided to just have a go at getting the lads back anyway didn't end well is what it is. Jay is then taken to dodgy with his serious shooter Dave sparks where both members are brought to there feet in order to grab any goods they are carrying. My character Jay gets to his feet after laughing at john falling over for a second comply with all demands dropping my guns and armour for anyone 880 approaches and decided to want a root through the pockets of the big jay after jay sticks his fingers up to do a bit of the old roleplay he is met with a instant bullet to the head and a very sarcastic and toxic comment from 880 saying "oops" after writing in LOOC complaining at the roleplay more to the fact the lack of he is met with another one saying "allow it jay" again later down the line Dave is at the racetrack roleplaying with posh when 'john' approaches sings a song and shoots again for no apparent reason ending the roleplay. The standard of roleplay from cutlass is frankly shocking compared to the old Kash RP where both parties could fully enjoy and generally have a laugh with it not be met by such toxicity. I provide the longer clip from the dodgy doctor, Dave's clip is to show the poor RP from john himself as well.
Link(s) To Any Evidence: https://medal.tv/games/gta-v/clips/km2dvMaQohyyD0aVA?invite=cr-MSxQT3AsMjQyNDI0OTY
https://medal.tv/games/gta-v/clips/km22spYlBCjV59mtd?invite=cr-MSxEQ2ssMjEyNTk0NTEy
Screenshots for ID
https://gyazo.com/6b40710a76b7b79ce12f92ebff2f0b47

Gyazo

gyazo.com

 

[Swayhh]

Hello mate,

Unsure as to why im being reported in the dodgy doctor situation as I never shot.

Regarding the clip of me shooting the hustler member, I believe this 35 second clip doesn't show a lot of context. I'm sure said hustler member can also agree that we were having a good little chat in the car in the moments leading up to his death.

Tensions are very high between the 2 gangs and executions are happening almost daily from both sides.

 

[BeercanButty]

Hello mate,

Unsure as to why im being reported in the dodgy doctor situation as I never shot.

Regarding the clip of me shooting the hustler member, I believe this 35 second clip doesn't show a lot of context. I'm sure said hustler member can also agree that we were having a good little chat in the car in the moments leading up to his death.

Tensions are very high between the 2 gangs and executions are happening almost daily from both sides.

Hi pal!
Executions must be roleplayed to a high standard where both parties could enjoy.
I don't think either situations prove to be a high standard of roleplay from a whitelisted group tensions may be high but again the server is about roleplay.

 

[Swayhh]

By any chance does Dave have a 3-5 min clip as per report guidelines as I believe that would show the roleplay I & cutlass as a whole provided him beforehand.. thanks!

Also, I can’t help but feel like because you lost a fight and after all the nights tit for tat in group members, you’re trying to cast a net and see which cutlass members you can catch in it because I never see these kind of reports from your side when you come out of a fight on top.

Cheers fella!

 

[BeercanButty]

By any chance does Dave have a 3-5 min clip as per report guidelines as I believe that would show the roleplay I & cutlass as a whole provided him beforehand.. thanks!

Also, I can’t help but feel like because you lost a fight and after all the nights tit for tat in group members, you’re trying to cast a net and see which cutlass members you can catch in it because I never see these kind of reports from your side when you come out of a fight on top.

Cheers fella!

No matter what all the wins Hustlers have got have ended in good roleplay otherwise we would of seen a report pop up from the cutlass side about this have you by any chance got this clip of all this roleplay that happened between you as I don't see coming from dodgy to casino much roleplay could of happened whilst zip tied and sat in a car. No matter what happened prior execution should be roleplayed to the highest standard not sing a nursery rhyme and shoot your gun standards should be a lot higher than this and think as a community everyone can agree doing things like this is to get a class clown reaction from the rest of your group as you hear the 'leader' of cutlass not say anything just start laughing when he was actually attempting to do some negotiation roleplay.

Thanks Jay Fell

 

[BeercanButty]

By any chance does Dave have a 3-5 min clip as per report guidelines as I believe that would show the roleplay I & cutlass as a whole provided him beforehand.. thanks!

Also, I can’t help but feel like because you lost a fight and after all the nights tit for tat in group members, you’re trying to cast a net and see which cutlass members you can catch in it because I never see these kind of reports from your side when you come out of a fight on top.

Cheers fella!

on the other hand at the start of Dave's clip you can see him clearly get pulled from posh's car
So how can you roleplay with someone with high quality that's not even in your car on the journey made from stab city to casino?

 

[Swayhh]

have you by any chance got this clip of all this roleplay that happened between you as I don't see coming from dodgy to casino much roleplay could of happened whilst zip tied and sat in a car.

Hello bud, last reply til the morning from me am shattered

You’re the player reporting an alleged rule break, so I’m assuming you have a 3-5 minute clip as per report guidelines.

Cheers!

 

[Swayhh]

on the other hand at the start of Dave's clip you can see him clearly get pulled from posh's car
So how can you roleplay with someone with high quality that's not even in your car on the journey made from stab city to casino?

I’m pretty sure your confused here jay mate, Even ask your fellow member if he would even like to comment himself. He was sat in my car for the journey made from stab city to the casino race track as he was telling me to shoot Cutlass’ tires and spin people out etc. I was white jester.

 

[Theo West]

on the other hand at the start of Dave's clip you can see him clearly get pulled from posh's car

Hi mate. when Dave submits his 3-5 minute clip you will clearly see he was in johns car the whole time from dodgy to casino. as you correctly say i took him out of johns car and pulled him to one side away from my gang and attempted negotiation with him. the reason he was pulled from my car is because once our conversation was finished we was going to move off but my gang decided he should pay as he attempted to kill us all moments before hand.

 

[andr3w]

Hello, i am ID 880 from last night

880 approaches and decided to want a root through the pockets of the big jay after jay sticks his fingers up to do a bit of the old roleplay he is met with a instant bullet to the head and a very sarcastic and toxic comment from 880 saying "oops"

My intentions was to restrain you at the time, in order to limit your movement and continue the roleplay accordingly. However my character was being hit with several derogatory remarks, implying that my character struggle with alcoholism. Nevertheless i instructed your character to put his hands up and surrender himself, where my character was met with further disrespect evidently leading to you catching a bullet. I will also add, yes my commentary was very sarcastic and toxic. My character is not a very pleasant person to begin with, especially towards people that recently attempted to hurt himself and his fellow gangmembers. I trust that you are able to seperate yourself from your character, and realise any in-game toxicity is not directed towards anyone OOC.

I am sure you are familiar with rule (G2.4) At all times you are to value your life, if you are clearly outnumbered or at an obvious disadvantage you should comply with demands.

To me it does appear your character is in quite a vulnerable position, having recently been injured to the point of incapacitation and held hostage by your opponents in a gang beef. I dont think alot of value of life is being displayed when you choose to " flip off " the people holding you at gunpoint giving verbal commands. To me this appears simular to other textbook examples at the dodgy docter, where people drop 1 bullet at a time to stall time and take the piss. Your efforts would have been better spent roleplaying your injuries and displaying some regard for you characters life.

That is all i would like to add, I am happy to answer any further staff questions.

 

[BeercanButty]

Hello, i am ID 880 from last night


My intentions was to restrain you at the time, in order to limit your movement and continue the roleplay accordingly. However my character was being hit with several derogatory remarks, implying that my character struggle with alcoholism. Nevertheless i instructed your character to put his hands up and surrender himself, where my character was met with further disrespect evidently leading to you catching a bullet. I will also add, yes my commentary was very sarcastic and toxic. My character is not a very pleasant person to begin with, especially towards people that recently attempted to hurt himself and his fellow gangmembers. I trust that you are able to seperate yourself from your character, and realise any in-game toxicity is not directed towards anyone OOC.

I am sure you are familiar with rule (G2.4) At all times you are to value your life, if you are clearly outnumbered or at an obvious disadvantage you should comply with demands.

To me it does appear your character is in quite a vulnerable position, having recently been injured to the point of incapacitation and held hostage by your opponents in a gang beef. I dont think alot of value of life is being displayed when you choose to " flip off " the people holding you at gunpoint giving verbal commands. To me this appears simular to other textbook examples at the dodgy docter, where people drop 1 bullet at a time to stall time and take the piss. Your efforts would have been better spent roleplaying your injuries and displaying some regard for you characters life.

That is all i would like to add, I am happy to answer any further staff questions.

A emote is not a good enough example for NVL it was a sly little gangster remark.
There's many different avenues you could of took that roleplay but you decided to just end that roleplay using a dodgy doctor as a loot llama from Fortnite because I guarantee if I still had my gun on me you would of made sure I was still on my feet but because I'm no use to you now you have your mythic legendary loot you end the roleplay for me and the rest of cutlass.
I was listening to demands and was genuinely trying to enjoy myself even if there was a bit of banter from myself to the cutlass member.
I don't want staff with pages and pages of replies to go through so I wont be replying any further as a I think the clip itself speaks volumes.
Thanks Legendary E-gangster Jay fell.

 

[OneShot]

Hello all,

Is there going to be a longer clip submitted to this report?

Not sure if we are waiting for more evidence or not?

 

[BeercanButty]

Hello all,

Is there going to be a longer clip submitted to this report?

Not sure if we are waiting for more evidence or not?

Hi OneShot
My apologise the clip was edited to send to me and he couldn't get the original file back afterwards I forgot I was even asked for it so my bad there.

 

[OneShot]

Thank you to everyone who provided their perspective.

After reviewing the evidence provided, we are taking action based on the execution of Dave at the racetrack. In this situation, the player identified as John Scott arrives while another Cutlass member is roleplaying with Dave (who is zip-tied), mumbles or quietly sings something under his breath, and then shoots Dave without any roleplay provided, then walking off. This shows no contribution to provide any sort of roleplay to the situation, and just abruptly ending it.

Regarding the earlier incident at Dodgy Doctor:
If you're being taken hostage and held at gunpoint, making a gesture like the middle finger at your hostage taker is not the best choice in this situation. There were arguably better ways to handle the situation by giving him another chance to comply to your demands, or having a bit of a back and forth conversation.

We want to remind all players involved especially whitelisted factions/groups, that roleplay should remain at a high standard at all times. Fast or throwaway executions, especially the OOC sarcasm or minimal RP, can easily lead to negative experiences and more reports. Let this serve as a reminder to makesure your actions build scenes up rather than shut them down.

Action Taken

CharID: 100462
Rule Broken: G7.3
Punishment: Permanent Ban (Unbanned 2 months ago)